Virtue Tax vs. Form5472.online: U.S. LLC Tax Filing for Israeli Owners (2026)
Editorial disclosure: This article was written by Arik Rozen, CPA -- the owner of Form5472.online, one of the two services compared below. All factual claims about Virtue Tax are drawn from publicly available information on their website and Google Business Profile. Readers should verify independently before choosing a provider.
Short Answer
Virtue Tax is a Ramat Gan-based firm specializing in U.S.--Israel cross-border taxation for individuals and businesses -- primarily serving Israeli residents who are U.S. citizens, dual nationals, or Americans living in Israel. They have a physical office and a strong local reputation (217 Google reviews, 4.9 stars).
Form5472.online is a remote U.S. CPA service that specializes specifically in IRS compliance for foreign-owned U.S. LLCs -- including Form 5472, Form 1065, and Form 1120 -- for non-U.S.-resident owners in Israel and more than 40 other countries. There is no physical office; all filings are handled remotely by a named, verifiable U.S. CPA.
The right choice depends on your situation: if you are an Israeli resident who is also a U.S. citizen or dual national with complex U.S.--Israel tax issues, Virtue Tax is a strong local option. If you are an Israeli resident who owns a U.S. LLC but are not a U.S. citizen, Form5472.online is built specifically for your filing.
Key Takeaways
Virtue Tax focuses on U.S.--Israel cross-border taxation -- primarily for U.S. citizens, dual nationals, and Americans living in Israel. Their core product is the Form 1040 / 1040-NR filing stack for individuals with ties to both countries.
Form5472.online focuses on foreign-owned U.S. LLC compliance -- primarily for non-U.S.-resident owners (Israeli, and 40+ other nationalities) who need Form 5472, Form 1065, or Form 1120 filed with the IRS.
A local Israeli accountant cannot sign a U.S. tax return. Only a U.S.-licensed CPA, enrolled agent, or attorney can prepare and sign a filing submitted to the IRS. Both Virtue Tax and Form5472.online state IRS authorization; verify credentials independently.
Pricing: Virtue Tax does not publish pricing publicly. Form5472.online charges $448 flat for Form 5472 + pro-forma 1120, with pricing for other forms available on the site.
Neither service is affiliated with the IRS or any government agency.
Who Each Service Is Built For
Question | Virtue Tax | |
Primary client | Israeli residents who are U.S. citizens, dual nationals, or Americans living in Israel | Non-U.S.-resident owners of U.S. LLCs -- any nationality, including Israeli |
Core filing | Form 1040 / 1040-NR, FBAR, Israeli tax returns | Form 5472 + pro-forma 1120, Form 1065, Form 1120 |
Physical location | Ramat Gan, Israel (Beit America, Tuval St 13) | Remote -- no physical office; U.S.-licensed CPA |
Countries served | Israel and United States | 40+ countries including Israel |
Language | Hebrew and English | English |
Pricing | Not published publicly -- contact for quote | $448 flat (Form 5472 + pro-forma 1120) |
Google reviews | 217 reviews, 4.9 stars (September 2026) | See Trustpilot -- tax-usa.net (parent firm): 249 reviews, 4.7 stars |
IRS authorization | Stated on website -- verify independently | Arik Rozen, CPA -- Virginia License #025991 -- publicly verifiable |
The Key Distinction: What Filing Do You Actually Need?
The most important question is not which firm has better reviews. It is: which filing do you actually need?
The answer depends on your personal situation as an Israeli resident who owns a U.S. company.
If you are an Israeli resident and NOT a U.S. citizen or green card holder
Your primary IRS obligation is Form 5472 + pro-forma Form 1120 (for a single-member LLC) or Form 1065 (for a multi-member LLC). You are not required to file a U.S. personal income tax return unless you have U.S.-source income.
This is the filing Form5472.online specializes in. It is also a filing Virtue Tax may handle -- but their stated focus and marketing is primarily on individual U.S. citizens and dual nationals, not on foreign-owned LLC compliance specifically.
If you are an Israeli resident AND a U.S. citizen or dual national
Your filing situation is significantly more complex. You must file a U.S. Form 1040 reporting your worldwide income, FBAR if you have foreign bank accounts exceeding $10,000, and potentially Form 5471 if you own an Israeli company. You may also need to file Israeli tax returns.
This is the situation Virtue Tax explicitly specializes in -- U.S.--Israel cross-border taxation for individuals with obligations in both countries. Their physical presence in Israel and Hebrew-language service are relevant advantages for this client profile.
The question to ask yourself: "Am I filing because I own a U.S. LLC as a non-U.S. person?" or "Am I filing because I am a U.S. citizen living in Israel?" The first situation points to Form5472.online. The second points to a cross-border specialist like Virtue Tax.
Can a Local Israeli Accountant File With the IRS?
This is a question many Israeli LLC owners ask -- and the answer is important.
An Israeli accountant (רואה חשבון) is licensed to practice in Israel under Israeli law. They are not automatically authorized to prepare and sign U.S. tax returns filed with the IRS. To represent clients before the IRS or sign U.S. tax returns, a preparer must be a U.S.-licensed CPA, an enrolled agent, or a U.S.-licensed attorney.
Virtue Tax states on their website that they are authorized to prepare U.S. tax returns and highlight credentials related to the IRS. Form5472.online identifies Arik Rozen, CPA (Virginia License #025991) as the named preparer -- a credential that is publicly verifiable through the Virginia Board of Accountancy.
If you are considering any Israeli firm for your U.S. LLC filing: ask specifically whether the preparer holds a U.S. CPA license, enrolled agent status, or U.S. attorney license -- and verify that credential through the relevant U.S. licensing board. An Israeli accountant who is not U.S.-licensed cannot legally sign your IRS filing.
What the IRS Penalty Context Means for Your Choice
The IRS penalty for failure to file Form 5472 is $25,000 per form, per year. This is not a minor administrative fee -- it exceeds the cost of professional preparation by a factor of 50 or more.
In this context, the most important question when choosing a provider is not price or location. It is: does this provider have a U.S.-licensed preparer who will sign the return, transmit it directly to the IRS, and provide evidence of filing?
Both Virtue Tax and Form5472.online state that they handle U.S. filings. The difference is specialization: Virtue Tax's stated expertise is U.S.--Israel individual taxation; Form5472.online's stated expertise is foreign-owned U.S. LLC compliance filings across 40+ countries.
Side-by-Side: Form 5472 Filing Specifically
Factor | Virtue Tax | |
Specializes in Form 5472 for foreign-owned LLCs | Not their primary stated focus | Yes -- core product |
Named U.S.-licensed CPA on file | Stated IRS authorization -- verify independently | Arik Rozen, CPA, Virginia #025991 |
Flat published price | Not published | $448 |
Serves Israeli clients remotely | Yes (also in person) | Yes -- remote only |
Serves non-Israeli clients | Focus is U.S.--Israel | Yes -- 40+ countries |
Zero-Penalty Guarantee | Not stated | Yes |
Late filing / prior year support | Not specified for Form 5472 | Yes |
Hebrew language support | Yes | No -- English only |
The Bottom Line
Virtue Tax is a well-reviewed Israeli firm with strong expertise in U.S.--Israel individual taxation. If you are an Israeli resident who is also a U.S. citizen or dual national, and you need someone who speaks Hebrew and understands Israeli tax law alongside U.S. obligations, they are a legitimate option to consider.
If you are an Israeli resident who owns a U.S. LLC but are not a U.S. citizen -- and your primary need is annual Form 5472, Form 1065, or Form 1120 compliance -- Form5472.online is built specifically for that filing, at a published flat fee, with a named and verifiable U.S. CPA.
The two services serve overlapping but distinct client profiles. The right choice depends on which profile matches your situation.
Verify the Facts in This Article
Virtue Tax website: virtuetax.com
Virtue Tax Google profile: Search "Virtue Tax Ramat Gan" on Google Maps -- 217 reviews, 4.9 stars as of September 2026
Form5472.online CPA license: Arik Rozen, Virginia License #025991 -- dhp.virginia.gov
IRS Form 5472 penalty: IRC Section 6038A -- $25,000 failure-to-file penalty
Related guide: What Israeli Owners of U.S. Companies Must File with the IRS (2026)
Israeli LLC owner who is not a U.S. citizen? Form 5472 filed by a named U.S. CPA -- remote, flat fee, Zero-Penalty Guarantee.
About the Author
Arik Rozen is a licensed U.S. CPA (Virginia License #025991) and the founder of Form5472.online and Tax-USA.net. He prepares and signs Form 5472, Form 1065, and Form 1120 filings for Israeli and international owners of U.S. companies across more than 40 countries. He is not affiliated with Virtue Tax, the IRS, or any government agency.
Comments